Alright, I’ll say it. There is one shot that really bothered me. Just one, I promise. When Julie returns to her room after unsuccessfully searching for her dog—which she thought was lost—the camera crash-zooms into the lovely Louis as he lies comfortably next to her mum in bed. I am not sure if it is a pathological condition similar to an allergy or an intolerance like the one I have for butter and coriander. As a matter of fact, I’m very rarely not distracted by zooms. They suddenly make me feel removed if temporarily from the story, unwillingly made aware of the craft.
Apart from that, The Eternal Daughter couldn’t have been worthier of the long wait, confirming Joanna Hogg as one of the finest auteurs of our time, and one of the few for whom I quite literally rush to the cinema as soon as anything new is released.
Constantly swinging between gentle hints of horror and comedy, introspective minimalism and family drama, The Eternal Daughter touches very different human territories, intriguingly exploring the hidden paths that connect them. Being a mother or not having been one, being a daughter, forever, and an artist.
Perhaps the real wonder of the film, Tilda Swinton is simply superb in two very distinct yet tightly related roles. The way the stolid grace of Rosalind’s formal composure counterpoints Julie’s fragility, their different sets of mannerisms, little rituals, miseries, and even language—especially in a film that I assume largely based on improvisation as per Joanna Hogg’s usual process—are perfectly convincing, measured, and beautifully nuanced. The Eternal Daughter certainly leaves a lot to unravel, but without ever sounding inaccessible or excessively intellectual. Just enough is given out to provoke, keep on the edge, set up a dialogue. A delicate balance that Hogg achieves on the page as well as through her elegant aesthetic instincts.
The slightly washed-out look and the iconic aspect ratio of the Super 16 camera—for my own record, an Arriflex 416 she used for the entire trilogy, to include both chapters of The Souvenir—frame an almost dioramic world in which we are progressively led to suspect that any detail to the tiniest minutiae might have a deeper reason to be. They come in a white cab, Julie leaves alone in a black one. Or the green glow that lights the eerie interiors at night, the hardly discernible noises ominously chiming in and out at all times, the many books, their titles, those about dreamers and those about adventurers. What are artists, methinks, if not both at once. And what is our mind, if not a mazy place with walls and doors, filled with all sorts of sounds.
